The president of the Professional Association of Judges (APM), Marthel Jean-Claude, gave an assessment of the judicial system, which has just started a new judicial year.
The president of the Professional Association of Judges (APM), Marthel Jean-Claude, assessed the state of the judiciary as it begins a new judicial year. Appearing on Magik 9’s morning show, the investigating judge discussed the problems plaguing the system, starting with the shortage of judges, poor working conditions, lack of legal aid for some detainees, prolonged pretrial detention, and low investment. According to APM president Marthel Jean-Claude, these issues prevent the justice system from fully carrying out its mission and contribute to the erosion of the rule of law.The president of the APM said that the crisis facing Haitian justice can’t be separated from the resources it gets. “Haitian justice never has the means to do its job,” he said, pointing out the gap between what courts need and the human and material resources they have.
In several courts, the number of judges is way below what’s needed. Judge Marthel Jean-Claude specifically mentioned courts that should have about ten judges but have to operate with just three to five. According to him, this situation makes some of the delays in handling cases unavoidable.On top of the low staffing levels, there are also the material working conditions. Some courts, especially those in Port-au-Prince and Croix-des-Bouquets, reportedly don’t have enough space to allow judges to work normally. Some judges are even forced to work in shifts, which, according to the president of the APM, affects the courts’ ability to handle cases on time.
Prolonged pretrial detention remains one of the main consequences of these difficulties. The president of the APM, however, acknowledges that the delays can’t be blamed solely on the lack of resources. Marthel Jean-Claude admits that there are some judges who are “lazy” or “negligent” and don’t always meet the deadlines set by law to handle cases. He believes that this situation is also partly due to the responsibility of oversight and disciplinary mechanisms.The (CSPJ) High Council of the Judicial Police, through its disciplinary body, as well as the Ministry of Justice, should, according to him, ensure that judges meet their professional obligations. He also calls for better management of the courts, particularly through deans who can track the progress of cases and provide more effective support for judges.
“We need deans, good managers who can push judges to do their job,” he basically argues, emphasizing the need for stricter oversight of how the courts operate.The way the justice system works is also affected, according to the APM, by difficulties in accessing legal aid. Some inmates who don’t have the financial means to hire a lawyer don’t actually get a court-appointed lawyer. Marthel Jean-Claude points out that having a lawyer is essential at several stages of the process. This situation can further slow down the handling of court cases. For the judge, issues with human resources, infrastructure, and access to legal defense all combine to feed a system where meeting court deadlines becomes particularly challenging.Beyond the dysfunctions of the judicial system, the president of the APM warns about their institutional consequences. “The rule of law has seriously declined in Haiti. That’s a fact,” says Marthel Jean-Claude, believing that the justice system, as one of the pillars of the rule of law, is not able to fully play its role.
In his view, a true rule of law requires that both citizens and public authorities be subject to the law, and that anyone who believes their rights have been violated can take their case to a court and get a judicial response. “We are not managing to build a rule of law,” he argues, seeing the weakening of justice as directly undermining the state’s ability to guarantee citizens’ rights.To get out of this situation, Marthel Jean-Claude believes that modernizing the judicial system necessarily requires investment. He laments the tiny budget allocated to justice, mentioning an amount representing about 1% of the national budget and the absence, in his view, of a real investment budget that would allow for the modernization of judicial infrastructure and equipment.
“Modernization comes at a cost,” he argues, believing that authorities need to be able to clearly define their budget priorities. According to the president of the APM, the lack of resources prevents the justice system from effectively tackling all the problems it The president of the APM is advocating for investments in justice. “Investing in justice is like investing in development,” he says. According to him, it’s hard to think about the country’s long-term economic development without a justice system that can ensure legal security, protect rights, and create an environment that reassures investors.faces.